Image: New Statesman

The UK’s Labour government is looking at making major changes to the country’s benefit system so that a jobless culture doesn’t begin to develop.  Amongst the changes are plans for people aged 18-24 to be made ineligible to apply for the two main sickness benefits.  These include Personal Independence Payments and Universal Credit.  The new plans have come from a review conducted by former Labour Health secretary Alan Milburn.   The government has welcomed the findings that come from the review but has not yet agreed to implement all the suggested measures.

Personal Independence Payments is a benefit that helps disabled people cope with the extra costs they may incur in their every day lives.  An example of this would be money to cover the costs of extra equipment they may need to manage their disability when they live independently.  This would include helping them to go out independently without having to rely on other people always being to take them everywhere.

Universal Credit helps people on low incomes or who are out of work.  Some people can also receive an extra payment if their disability or health condition makes working difficult.  It is intended to help put them on a more level footing with able bodied people.  It also avoids any elements of discrimination or prejudice.

The report recommends placing people under twenty-five who were on such benefits in a new system designed to help young people find work better.  It can also help them with education and training opportunities.  Those involved would receive a new payment called the youth allowance that would depend on their income and circumstances.

The extra Universal Credit payment for people whose health affects their ability to work would be removed for this age group.

PIP would be replaced by an Additional Costs Allowance to help young people with long-term disability-related expenses. The review says this payment should not depend on someone’s income.

Young people with the most severe disabilities or are unlikely to be able to work would receive separate financial support.  The study recommends that this should be more generous than the existing system and be able to cope with the rising costs of every day living.  There would also be a local fund to help people with shorter term needs.

The review recommends keeping disabled children on Disability Living Allowance until they turn 18. At present, young people generally have to apply for PIP when they turn 16.

Young people would receive more help to find employment, apprenticeships or training. This could include an adviser who helps them make a plan based on their personal circumstances.

Young people who receive the new benefit would be expected to take part in suitable work, education or training opportunities to help them find suitable employment opportunities. People who are already receiving benefits could also be affected when they are reassessed.  The government has not decided however, how the changes would work and this could take time.

 Disability charity Contact has warned that some young people could lose significant amounts of money, especially if they currently receive the extra Universal Credit payment because their health affects their ability to work. Some could lose around £430 a month from this payment alone. (source: https://contact.org.uk/about-contact/news-and-views/welfare-proposals-in-milburn-review-explained/)

Prime Minister Andy Burnham endorsed the “principles” of the review and appointed Milburn to lead a new youth opportunities unit, while Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden rejected claims that young people are “snowflakes and shirkers” and called for a broader focus on long-term life chances.

Most Labour MPs who spoke in a Commons debate focused on employment support rather than opposing the benefit cuts outright—a contrast to the rebellion that blocked Sir Keir Starmer’s planned welfare cuts in 2025.

Some left-wing Labour MPs, including Nadia Whittome, Emma Lewell, and Apsana Begum, warned that cutting health-related benefits risks pushing young disabled people into poverty and repeating past harm from work capability assessments.